Tilikum: The Blackfish effect

Tilikum: The Blackfish effect
24.02.2016
World
Tilikum: The Blackfish effect
Exploitation for shows

Tilly, dear Tilly. Six years already. We fight for you and yours. We do not give up. Resist a little longer, we are moving towards your freedom, towards your freedom. Your desperate gesture has been heard. Continue to resist!

Today, after thirty-three years of detention, Tilikum, aka Tilly, is subdued
by tranquilizers, floating motionless and facing a wall. His dorsal fin is so flaccid that it hangs on his side. Sadly, echoing The One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest, Tilikum was punished for wanting to break his chains. Seaworld, who wants him alive, has put him in a chemical straightjacket. He is a « breeding bull ». His seed is highly prized.

However, his suicidal revolt will not have been in vain: thanks to him, all
captive orcas can now benefit from a new public gaze. The Blackfish
effect continues to eat away at SeaWorld and soon, all companies that
exhibit orcas in glass jars will have to deal with this change of opinion. Tilikum is a whistle-blower, a Spartacus amongst orcas!

At sea, no orca has attacked a human. In captivity, there have been
hundreds of incidents. Why this violence? Orcas are not happy; SeaWorld explains that they are receiving the best veterinary care and the best gourmet food? No, they are not. Orcas have extremely developed brains. Maybe even more developed than that of the human brain…

When it was revealed in Death at SeaWorld and then in Blackfish in
2013, Tilikum’s story moved the world. Clearly the victim of an
industrial lobby, his violent attack has paradoxically revealed all the « humanity » of captive orcas, all the suffering that these giant slaves feel, locked up in an overcrowded pit, and that sometimes makes them swing from the « dark side » of the force, to use John Hargrove’s words.

Born in the icy waters of Iceland, Tilly was kidnapped from his mother and
tribe in 1983, at the age of two. He later became a gigantic male, but he was still a shy male. At Sealand of the Pacific where he was brought, he was locked up every night in a shed with two aggressive females. Every morning he came out covered in wounds. And one day, at the end of his nerves, he dragged his trainer by the foot and drowned her. A little later, he killed a drifter who had probably plunged into his pool. But for SeaWorld, the moods of killer whales must not be known. Tilly’s past has been concealed. Until the death of Dawn Brancheau, February 24, 2010.

Tilikum’s mad despair did not go unnoticed. His miserable life, his anger, this dignity that he desperately tries to win back, inspires our struggle. We do not want killer whales to be enslaved any longer. We do not want to see them suffer anymore. We must save Tilikum and the fifty-five other orcas that are still held in the world!

Please sign and diffuse our petition for closing dolphinariums!

Tilikum died in January 2017.

Vicky: saved from circus hell

Vicky: saved from circus hell
20.02.2016
Europe
Vicky: saved from circus hell
Exploitation for shows

After several years in the hell that is the circus, Vicky the elephant was freed by One Voice. Today she enjoys a peaceful retirement in semi-liberty, and most importantly in the company of another elephant…

It was in the Paris area that One Voice investigators found Vicky, an elephant then aged 42. When we rescued her in January 2006, we created a legal precedent that at last offers hope for all animals held in circuses, and reminds the circus world of its legal duty to care for the animals they have. In the course of this rescue operation we exposed just how much animal suffering and isolation underlies this « entertainment » business.

Physical and mental misery

Vicky is typical of the damage that circuses causes to the animals they exploit. After several years entertaining humans, in living conditions that were totally inadequate, she developed stereotypical behaviour (repetitive swaying). On the site where the circus set up at the start of 2006, it was not difficult to spot the trailer where she was hidden away since it was rocking from side to side. Aside from her mental deterioration, this elephant was also suffering physically. The vet brought in to oversee her journey could do little more than document her injuries : as well as multiple untreated wounds, paralysis of a back leg, caused by unnatural repetitive movements, and paralysis of the trunk, consistent with being endlessly struck by her trainer. These two types of injury are classic amongst elephants abused in circuses.

A wretched life

But there was even more to the suffering of this elephant. In the days before her rescue, One Voice investigators had her under surveillance and observed that she never left her trailer. She had no access to daylight other than briefly when the circus people came to feed her or clean her lorry-cage. Chained up day and night, she could not move, and there was no heating to protect her from the cold. These living quarters were unsuitable and unacceptable, flouting basic regulations on keeping wild animals.

A carefully supervised liberation

The physical and mental state of Vicky somewhat complicated her rescue. We had to « lift » Vicky from her jailers with a police escort. Once our team was sure the elephant was well away, we transferred her to a lorry specially adapted for taking her to Poland, to a vast paddock in a specialist park, and best of all with the company of another elephant survivor.

The rescue in pictures

The rescue and relocation of Vicky required special care and multiple precautions to not endanger her life. These four videos tell the story of her rescue, closely monitored by the French national office for hunting and wild animals (ONCFS), in cooperation with local authorities.

• https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dtFEFrxXKL4
• https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HvId-AM6jZI
• https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fpg7i4XV5wk
• https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kKtbhPLZiPo

Valentin’s last voyage

Valentin’s last voyage
11.02.2016
France
Valentin’s last voyage
Exploitation for shows

Valentin was born on the 13th of February 1996 in the confines of a pool, no place for an orca. He would die there on the 12th of October 2015, at the age of 19, having never left Marineland, Antibes.

Birth

The orcas circle nervously in the pool. Shouka and Kim, as well as Sharkane, the Godmother, who is supervising the birth and who will soon guide the child to the surface. First the tailfin, followed by the body, little by little from Freya’s stomach. In a cloud of blood, Valentin enters the world. He discovers the tiny universe in which he will live for his for his whole life: the concrete walls, the turbulent, chlorine tasting water, the noise. And above the water, he sees buildings, stands and humans walking around. Walls everywhere. The orca basin as it was in 1996 is now home to the dolphins. Five inmates are contained there. First of all, Freya has to teach her son not to injure himself on the concrete walls, and to learn how to break his momentum so as not to hit the walls whilst playing. Nothing prepares a cetacean, even one born in captivity, to live in a tank.

Training

At six months, Valentin takes part in his first shows, swimming under his mother and nursing to the background noise of clapping. When weaned at the age of one, he quickly learns from the trainers that if he has to work if he wants fish. He must be disciplined and not play around during the show. He also has to accept the separation from his mother, isolated in another basin. Little Prince Valentin becomes very popular, with a fan club and a Facebook page. Teenagers exchange his best photos annotated with hearts. We easily recognise his beauty spot to the right of his throat.

Sorrow

Val is the second orca to be born in Marineland after Shouka, Sharkane’s daughter, her oldest of three years and his playmate. He is also the first surviving child of Freya, who was thought to be infertile because of previous x-ray treatment. Before Val, she had given birth to her first stillborn in March 1991, then a second in 1993. After Val’s birth, she would go on to lose three more children, in 2001 and 2003. So you can imagine how much she loves and protects her son. After her last miscarriage, an already unwell Freya drops into a depression. Floating away from the others, she doesn’t participate in the shows anymore, and no longer obeys the trainers. She comes up occasionally and hits her head against the windows of the main pool, again and again, consumed by sadness.

Valentin takes this all in, and suffers to see his mother in pain. She had already been hit hard by the departure of her adored half-sister Shouka in 2002. The young orca had been sent to Vallejo in the United States, where she would live on her own for ten years. As for Valentin, he begins to exhibit stereotypical displacement behaviour which he will repeat for the rest of his life: his stomach in the air, hitting his forehead against the sides of his pool next to the « trainers cave ».

Grief

Upon Freya’s death in June 2015, Valentin’s world would collapse once again. His mother was the last orca caught by Marineland. Constantly ill during her short life, she had visible scars from x-rays on her side. A « heart-attack, » declared Marineland, but Freya had other reasons to die. Leaving behind a bewildered little family in her wake, unguided having lost their matriarch, it is a terrible shock for the five surviving members. But Marineland has no time to let them grieve for Freya, putting on a show the very same evening, to « distract » them from their sorrow and to not lose clients. Valentin however, is not « distracted » by the show, nor by any future show. A feeling of emptiness and abandonment takes hold that only the son loved by a orca can understand.

A brutal change in power relations takes place within the walls of the basin: Freya now dead, Val is no longer the protected little prince. His social status collapses and he finds himself in front of his nagging half-sister in charge of two children, and his shy half-brother, Inouk. Tensions build and fights erupt. Freya is no longer there to keep order. By summer 2015, Valentin is a shadow, floating motionless on his own in a corner of the chemical blue pool. Around Val, a fairground atmosphere: incessant music, the noise of visitors, food odours and lighting until late at night. Valentin doesn’t listen any longer, he hardly moves anymore.

Death

The days go by. The temperature increases. Then suddenly, the sky opens. Heavy rain falls on the region. Marineland is submerged by mud and dirt and the basin waters become yellowy brown. The survivors are closed off into a small lateral basin to protect them from the infected water. They fight and they bite each other. Wikie falls ill and is isolated. Is Valentin still alive? Did he not survive seeing the collapse of his family? Has he swallowed something toxic? Has he been injured by a stand chair catapulted by the wind? Have his injuries become infected? Did he die during the flooding? We know nothing.

On Monday the 12^th of October, Marineland management publish a brief press release: « Marineland is extremely sad to announce the death today at 12.00 of Valentin, an orca born in the park », adding two days later: « The first physical examination of Valentin, who died a few days ago, shows an intestinal torsion like that which can occur in a horse or a dog ». But orcas are not dogs, and twisted intestines caused by stress don’t happen to them at sea.

Every day, they travel an average of 160km and dive to depths of more than 100 metres. Valentin only completed one short journey in his short life, from Marineland Antibes to the knackery. An enormous crane lifted his body from the crib that had become his grave, as it had done for many others before him. Since the opening in 1970 of Marineland, Antibes, nine other adults have died young, on top of all the miscarriages. Calypso died at 11 years of age, Clovis at 4, Kim at 14, Betty at 13, Kim2 at 27, Sharkane at 23, Tanouk at 14, and Freya at 32. The average age of a wild orca is between 50 and 80 years old. Granny, the matriarch of J Pod has reached 104 years of age. Valentin, he only made it to 19…

If his parents had not been captured, today Valentin would be a wonderful male cutting through the waves in the Iceland sea with his big straight fin. He would swim alongside his mother, still alive with her life ahead of her, and with all of his brothers, sisters, uncles and aunts. He would hunt herring, play, have many close friends in other tribes, and have some children here and there. Every day, his life would be a new adventure in the icy fjord water. But man had decided otherwise. Valentin spent his life in a dungeon, his stomach ravaged by ulcers, his chin cut from rubbing against the concrete tanks, and his backfin drooping over time.
This is not how orcas live.

Open a dolphinarium: the strange idea of Beauval Zoo

Open a dolphinarium: the strange idea of Beauval Zoo
10.02.2016
France
Open a dolphinarium: the strange idea of Beauval Zoo
Exploitation for shows

All French dolphin aquariums, ‘dolphinariums’, were opened last century. However, since then the « Blackfish effect » has opened the public’s eyes to the suffering experience by captive cetaceans.

All French dolphin aquariums, ‘dolphinariums’, were opened last century. However, since then the « Blackfish effect » has opened the public’s eyes to the suffering experience by captive cetaceans. In the United States, Gabriela Cowperthwaite’s documentary has had an impact, worrying SeaWorld shareholders with the financial losses resulting from the revelations. As their American counterpart, Marineland Antibes finds itself restricted to offering « educational » shows and defending itself from this « slander » by posting videos. There is a lot to suggest that these media strategies won’t save the Antibes park from the same financial fate as SeaWorld.

Two independent companies are attempting with caution to breakout with dolphinarium projects. Amnéville Zoo in North Eastern France has already been singed by the general outburst following their project. Beauval Zoo remains cautious. The sudden interest seen on the web at the idea requires them to justify themselves.

In a message published on its Facebook page, the zoo defended their project: « Modern zoos invest permanently in internationally managed rearing and breeding programmes. The success of these programmes is frequently confirmed by increased birth-rates. In the case of dolphins, the European population in animal parks is continually increasing; 34 males and 21 females have been born between 2009 and 2014. »

It is impossible to verify these figures. There is no inventory of captive cetaceans at a European level comparable to the Marine Mammal Inventory Report established by the American government, which is very disappointing. However, the deaths announced in the press show us that captive cetaceans rarely live longer than twenty years. The in-breeding and strange living conditions reduce their physical and psychological resistance and dramatically reduce their life expectancy. The announced extinction of the captive population will sooner or later force the dolphinariums to recapture dolphins or to « save » new « deaf » orcas like Morgan.

If artificial insemination programmes are already doubtful for elephants or great apes, they obviously don’t make sense for cetaceans. The species Tursiops Truncates (common bottlenose dolphin), living in these aquariums is not in danger, according to the UCN. Captive breeding only serves to renew stocks of these show animals. None of them are ever put back into the sea.

The zoo continues to assert: « We unconditionally support the ban of any capture of wild dolphins. Likewise, we strongly condemn the acts that have taken place in the Japanese bay of Taiji ». Good, but in announcing its intention to open a dolphinarium–in the distant future, it specifies–Beauval Zoo is sending out a clear signal to developing countries: « Open marine parks! This industry makes money! ».

Don’t forget that this attraction dates from another century. It no longer corresponds to public sensitivity, morals, or scientific interest. We don’t reduce non-human beings to slavery, these beings who have self-awareness, have cultures and dialects and a sophisticated social life, but who above all have moral and emotional qualities which humanity should be jealous of.

Keeping cetaceans in captivity isn’t really the ‘done-thing anymore’, it’s out of fashion.

Last minute change. Beauval Zoo has given up its dolphin aquarium. In the last few months, One Voice has not given up putting on the pressure? It’s a great victory!

The abolition is happening! Keep fighting for the closure of French dolphin aquariums, sign the petition!