One Voice in action on 9 June in Auxerre against the biggest French breeder of dogs that are destined for the laboratories

One Voice in action on 9 June in Auxerre against the biggest French breeder of dogs that are destined for the laboratories

One Voice in action on 9 June in Auxerre against the biggest French breeder of dogs that are destined for the laboratories
07.06.2018
Auxerre
One Voice in action on 9 June in Auxerre against the biggest French breeder of dogs that are destined for the laboratories
Animal testing

The One Voice association lodged a complaint against the intensive breeding of dogs in Mézilles in the department of Yonne. Saturday June 9, from 2.00pm to 4.00pm, One Voice organizes a rally in front of the prefecture of Auxerre to demand the closure of the CEDS, the largest French dog breeding provider for laboratories. The same day at 2.00pm a delegation will be received by the Chief of Staff of the Prefect of Yonne.

One Voice was authorized to use a bailiff who was able to undertake findings in the ECSR on 24 May. Following his report, he lodged a complaint against this farm for ill-treatment and lack of care. The association also requires that all the dogs must be handed over to the bailiff.

The breeder requires the Prefecture to endorse an increase in its capacity which is already effective

The Breeding Centre of the Domaine des Souches (CEDS) is asking the State for permission to expand its reception capacity, while it has already exceeded the maximum capacity that is allowed.

A complaint for lack of care and ill-treatment

It is apparent from the report of the bailiff that females are used for breeding each time they are on heat until they are seven years old. On that day, the keepers were clearly understaffed as the report mentions only three keepers were on site. Only one keeper is there at night, but does not watch the animals. So, when the females give birth, how can they benefit from assistance or care in case of complications? Once born, the puppies live locked up with their mother in the same concrete box for 12 weeks, the only « comfort » expected: a plastic bin and sawdust on the ground. There is no trace of any games or other means of isolation for the mothers.

After two months, the puppies are weaned, separated from their mothers, and grouped in the « storage area », where there no « no playground » is planned: nature is absent, except behind the fence. Those who survive are sent to laboratories as early as 10 months of age. When females can no longer reproduce, they suffer the same fate. The complaint of One Voice reports many failings.

The Law and the people demand less cruelty and animal testing

The Beagles and Golden Retrievers are dogs chosen to supply the laboratories applying animal experimentation protocols because they
are soft and docile. Since 2016, the quantity of dogs used in the laboratories is increasing. When we know how much they are protected by French law, it makes one imagine what sort of life there is for rabbits, hamsters, mice…

And yet, 83% of French people are in favour of stopping animal testing (IPSOS survey for One Voice December 2016).

The European regulation is clear on the subject, it makes it explicit in the form of the 3R rule: Reduce, Replace, Refine. Member countries of
the European Union must replace animals with alternative research methods (computer simulations, stem cells, etc.), refine tests to make them less painful, and most importantly, reduce the number of animals used. The state must therefore finance the search for alternative methods when they do not exist, and scientists have the duty to implement these methods when they exist.

Consistent with these provisions, One Voice calls for the closure of this French breeding facility, instead of its expansion and is supported in this process by more than 40,000 people. These supporters have all signed the petition over a six-week period after its posting on One Voice’s website. Many associations make up the main European coalition in this area, the ECEAE, European Coalition to End Animal Experimentation, who support One Voice – of which we are the French representative. The local collective « Let’s close the CEDS » who is also in solidarity with this action.

Saturday June 9 at 2.00 pm, the association will be received by the Cabinet Director of the Prefect of Yonne, the assembly will leave after this
appointment.

We are at your disposal for any further information and will be available for any interview at request until 1:30 pm on the day of the meeting, or after 3 pm that same day.

Photograph taken from the complaint filed with the Attorney General of Auxerre

Share on

Four dogs and two cats killed by gunshots!

Four dogs and two cats killed by gunshots!

Four dogs and two cats killed by gunshots!
06.06.2018
France
Four dogs and two cats killed by gunshots!
Domestic animals

Six victims. Six innocent deaths, six violent deaths and a terrified family. This is the result of a fit of anger. Against this man is the threat that he could do it again – and against whom? – One Voice pressed charges. We will be in court in Laon on Thursday, June 7th.

The constant death threats, and the blackmail of suicide, had kept the whole family alive for many years. The unstable and violent sexagenarian, sickly jealous, found it easy to insult. This hunter was an imposing figure, with gun in hand, reproaching his son and grandson for being too present in his life and being « shits ». To put pressure on his relatives, he also threatened the animals, of which he acted on…

On April 4th, 2018, he killed four dogs and two cats by shooting them in the head. He then called his ex-wife to threaten her with death and rushed home, then after firing at the door he fled! Violence is blind, she does not choose her victims. Who will be next to perish by his hand? This is what worries the relatives of the defendant, who testified to being afraid that he will « finish what he started » while leaving custody.

Our campaign, so that the “link” existing between the violence exerted against humans and against animals is recognized in France. It appears again in this example the meaning of this link.

It is urgent that the law take into account the danger that these people represent for the whole of society, and are proactive in preventing them from continuing to harm!

Our Cell Zoé has pressed charges of wilful harm on a pet (six in this case), and demands an exemplary sentence during the hearing that will take place in Laon on June 7th.

You too must act to ensure that this link is criminally recognized and that vulnerable people, whether animal or human, are properly protected. Please sign our petition.

Moana a child from a syringe

Moana a child from a syringe

Moana a child from a syringe
04.06.2018
Antibes
Moana a child from a syringe
Exploitation for shows

Moana, the first orca that was born by artificial insemination in Europe suffered the rejection of his mother. His sister has been sent thousands of miles away, they cannot play together anymore. His life is one of boredom and obedience and with surrogate parents …

Moana is a male killer whale born in Marineland Antibes on March 16th, 2011. His mother is Wikie and his father is Ulises, a wild orca captured in Iceland and held at SeaWorld in San Diego, California.

Moana was the third orca in the world to be born by artificial insemination, and the first ever in Europe. It is unclear whether this mode of reproduction, still experimental, will one day affect the health of this infant. The trainers say he is smart. This means for them that by the age of one year, Moana had already performed a range of forced movements, which most orcas only learn later, after long years of training. He had understood everything just by looking at his mother. And we understand his enthusiasm to do well!

$(document).ready(function(){ $(‘.diaporama’).bxSlider(); });

In the closed, confines of the world where he is forced to live, within this glass jar without any rocks, any seaweed or any fish where he has been turning around and around in circles since his birth, the slightest distraction is worth its weight in gold. One would fight to be able to repeat those human words over and over again, not unlike a scratched record. Such is the life that is imposed on Wikie, so much boredom weighs heavy on the this big pool where under the heat of the midday sun live these big black fish with the sadness in their eyes.

Moana was very independent very early. Too early perhaps, because very quickly his mother left the trainers the burden of his education.

In 2013, the small orca with a hopeless future became the older brother of Keijo, a baby clearly neither desired nor expected. A year later, his half-sister Amaya was born from the same father as him. But he will never have the happiness of playing with her, since she is was taken thousands of miles away, to the pools of San Diego.

KANGAROO, the interview

KANGAROO, the interview

KANGAROO, the interview
03.06.2018
France
KANGAROO, the interview
Wildlife

We are organizing the first two venues of the documentary « Kangaroo, a love-hate story » in France. This is the exclusive interview of its directors, Mick McIntyre and Kate McIntyre Clere and Pr. Peter Singer who shed light on this issue.

How was this project born? What was the trigger?

Kangaroos are one of the most recognizable symbols in the world and have always held a fascination for us. No film had explored this icon before. We set out to make a story that celebrated this magnificent animal but soon discovered that the kangaroo was at the heart of a bitter, complex and divided situation in Australia. We were shocked to learn that millions of kangaroos are shot each year as so-called pests and sold for profit. To find out where it started and why it still happens today, we needed to investigate the origins of an industry and government partnership, which has become the largest wildlife slaughter in the world. Where had the ideology come from that a native animal that has lived in Australia for millions of years could be a national problem? How and when did Australians start believing kangaroos were a pest and therefore must be eliminated?

«One of the worst elements is the treatment of the joeys — when the mother is shot, they often die slowly. Sometimes they are not in the pouch at the time, and hop away into the dark (kangaroo shooting usually takes place at night) and then they often die of thirst or starvation. »Pr Peter Singer

How many kangaroos die every year? You say the number of kangaroos isn’t growing, in opposition with your government’s assessment, why?

One of the biggest issues we faced in making this film was examining the population figures that the Australian government published every year about how many kangaroos there are. So we had to unpack the survey methodology that the government uses to get those numbers. No surprise we discovered how flawed the methodology is and so we got expert testimony in how inflated the govt estimates are.We learnt that the govt has been using these inflated figures as a way of abdicating responsibility for the conservation of the kangaroo. On the subject of how many are killed we discovered that with the growth of the commercial kangaroo industry, so-called pest mitigation, recreational and illegal shooting, as well as road-kill and other accidental / collateral death, there is still very little data collected of the number of kangaroo deaths that occur daily. Some scientists and conservationists are reporting both local and regional extinctions. They don’t know how many are being killed.

What reasons do the Australian government give to consider kangaroos as pests?

When Australia was colonized by white settlers 230 years ago, the kangaroos were killed as meat for eating, but as sheep and cattle herds grew over the next 100 years, many people stopped eating them, though they were still frequently killed for sport. It didn’t take long before the white settlers began to see kangaroos as competing with their stock for feed, and damaging their crops. Later, when ecosystems collapsed from overstocking of introduced livestock, the farmers blamed the kangaroos for the damage, and decided they needed to be removed from the landscape; the Australian government facilitated this, labelling them as noxious species, and paying out millions in bounties. The idea that kangaroos are seen as a pest has continued through to the present day.

«Animals may cause some loss to humans, of course, when they eat the crops we plant, or in the case of kangaroos, when they reduce the amount of grass available for cattle or sheep. But they are never simply a pest. They are also sentient beings with lives of their own to lead, and we should find better means of limiting their numbers and living alongside them.
The Australian government isn’t doing enough to protect its wildlife at all. They are too influenced by the graziers. »Pr Peter Singer

Why most of the killing is taking place at night in secret?

In filming KANGAROO we found that over time that the killing of kangaroos as so called pests had been replaced by killing millions of kangaroos for profit. The killing is government sanctioned and the shooting is done in the dead of night often miles from anywhere. There is no onsite monitoring of the killing. As kangaroos are nocturnal marsupials they are active at night and therefore shooting them in vast numbers is easiest at this time; they are also very vulnerable to the spotlight hunting method, often turning to face the light. Permits are sought to remove kangaroos from the landscape for many reasons from agricultural, land clearing for development and other human events. Although codes of practice have been developed for farmers and shooters to reduce cruelty, in many cases this is impossible to police, and research has found that non-compliance is widespread. We had whistleblowers come forward and give us first hand eyewitness accounts of the brutal treatment of kangaroos and their young joeys.

Which country or continent imports the most kangaroo products? What are they?

The largest importers of kangaroo parts are in Europe. They import kangaroo meat for pet food, meat for human consumption and skins for fashion and sports goods. The key importers for meat products are Belgium, Germany, Netherlands and France.

Are there farms that raise kangaroos for this?

No kangaroos are a wild animal that cannot be farmed. This is a wildlife slaughter.

In which conditions did you film? Was it dangerous?

For so many reasons this was an uncomfortable movie to make. Probably because its an uncomfortable issue. Most pople are shocked when they find out what is going on with the kangaroo – every night ! To find out the mass scale on which kangaroos are hunted was definitely alarming and to witness these mass shootings was traumatic. Witnessing first hand the treatment of joeys and the wounded animals dying slow deaths was disturbing. There was definitely some situations where it was more of a men’s business situation, shooting kangaroos at night, out in the wilderness. It was essential to have some strong guys on our team.

How did you choose the locations to film? How long did you film and where?

To produce « Kangaroo, » we had to travel thousands of kilometers across the magnificent red dusty Australian outback. As kangaroos are spread across the country we filmed in many national parks and farms (some as big as 300,000 acres) capturing images of the landscape and ecosystem of the kangaroo. The kangaroo themselves are shy herbivores so filming them is challenging  so it took many trips to get enough filming done. We were told by famers that we could film the ‘plagues’ of kangaroos that are so often propagated in the Australian media but after 4 years filming we never came across this.In fact we were shocked by how few kangaroos we found. We also filmed in the countries who are involved in the import of kangaroo parts, like the UK and The Netherlands, we also filmed in countries that have banned the import of kangaroo parts like Russia who have banned importing kangaroo meat due to meat hygiene and California where they have a blanket ban of importing any kangaroo parts. We wanted to give the audience a comprehensive picture of what is happening to the kangaroo globally.

Who did you interview for the movie and why? What is their input?

We knew we would have to immerse ourselves in all aspects of the story and we worked to get interviews from the many differing stakeholders. We interviewed indigenous Australians, scientists, commercial shooters, farmers, politicians, artists, wildlife carers, chefs and activists
Key to the telling this story was investigating the details behind the largest wildlife slaughter in the world, to find out where it all started and why it still happens today.. We uncovered many people who have a strong emotional connection to kangaroos juxtaposing many different opinions on their status as wildlife and their « management » as pests.

«As an Australian, I have been involved with animal issues in Australia for more than 40 years, so i am familiar with the enormous scale of the kangaroo slaughter in this country, and also with the fact that many kangaroos do not die instantly. I want to see this brought to an end, so I welcome a film that exposes how kangaroos are treated in Australia. »Pr Peter Singer

What will the audience take away?

With breathtaking footage of kangaroos in the wild, we hope this film will give the audience an up-close experience of this unique species and bring to the table a conversation that Australians seem reluctant to have. It’s time that people in Australia and across the world know what is going on with this internationally celebrated icon and ask the question: Why is no one responding to this barbaric treatment and wholesale slaughter?«We need to foster attitudes of respect for all animals, and give more consideration to their interests.

Please ask your government not to permit the import of products made from kangaroos: meat, fur, or leather. And of course never buy these products yourself. »Pr Peter Singer

Tickets for the venues of Paris (5th June 2018) and of Strasbourg (6th June 2018) can be purchased in advance.

 

Picture Credits: Cover: Hoping Pictures (Kangaroo Dundee, Mick McIntyre & Kate McIntyre Clere / Peter Singer by Aletta Vaandering

Art engages children against captivity

Art engages children against captivity

Art engages children against captivity
02.06.2018
France
Art engages children against captivity
Exploitation for shows

We have allowed a facilitator from a school near Narbonne to raise the awareness of children aged 4 to 11 about animals in circuses, during the spring break. Captivity, training, homelessness, they have learned that no, « animals are not clowns ».

Delighted, Delphine, the host, told us that one of the children, « who loved to go to the circus, and planned to go with her Mother to Marineland because she loves animals and is very interested in them! Will never again return to a circus or to a water park, she has made several drawings about animals in captivity and where she writes « do not applaud these poor animals ».

This young child, like many others, has been touched by the information that One Voice has shared with them, and they have been full of ideas on how to teach the adults around them the reality of traveling circuses.

Among their ideas, one bold individual reported to the facilitator of the project: « The children had proposed to go to the cash desk of the circus and instead of buying a ticket, would announce in front of everyone that they were very sad for the animals and that they would never give them any more money.  »

Discover below, the achievements of the children. They have touched us, very moving. And you?

$(document).ready(function(){ $(‘.diaporama’).bxSlider(); });

#CirquesSansAnimaux: One Voice makes available a “decree” more solid for the communities

#CirquesSansAnimaux: One Voice makes available a « decree » more solid for the communities

#CirquesSansAnimaux: One Voice makes available a “decree” more solid for the communities
01.06.2018
France
#CirquesSansAnimaux: One Voice makes available a “decree” more solid for the communities
Exploitation for shows

All the animals held in the circuses suffer from captivity, homelessness, and from the training: boredom, confinement, lack of retreat from humans, of whom they have an instinctive fear of, scary noises, brutality … The list seems infinite, so much so that their well-being is denied.

This is especially true of wild animals in danger in this environment. Their natural life should be respected. They should not be subject to indiscrimination by humans, nor even dominated by them … but protected.

In the absence of a national law that prohibits their exploitation in circuses, many municipalities in France have decided not to endorse such shows. In real democracies, the mayors rely on the vote from the city council, to then enforce the opinions of their fellow citizens. Unfortunately, the decisions taken following the voting and of certain decrees are open to legal challenges, and are often annulled as a result of the recourse from the Circuses and their lawyers.

Therefore, rich is our expertise in the field, and always in the perspective of proposing solutions to our requirements for societal advances, we have available to any municipality that wishes to develop a solid decree « a complete package », together with a consultation guide book. One Voice and its legal team stand ready to assist municipalities who wish to act against animal exploitation for entertainment.

Do you want your municipality to commit to circuses without animals? Contact us, we will send the relevant documents directly to your town hall.

The trial of repeat offenders of Oise: One Voice demands an exemplary sentence!

The trial of repeat offenders of Oise: One Voice demands an exemplary sentence!

The trial of repeat offenders of Oise: One Voice demands an exemplary sentence!
30.05.2018
Oise
The trial of repeat offenders of Oise: One Voice demands an exemplary sentence!
Domestic animals

On Thursday May 31st 2018 will be the trial of a couple of repeat offenders, whom against we filed a complaint for ill-treatment. One year after our seizure of animals at their home, the Cell Zoe will be in the court of Senlis so that they will never again abuse their victims.

Long-term vigilance

We unfortunately knew the owners all too well. The same muddy grounds, the same house, the smell of animal waste, their infections and corpses …

Since 2004, we have been monitoring their activities. In 2011 already, our Cell Zoe had saved from their « establishment », 46 dogs in a deplorable state and obtained a court prosecution for serious abuse and acts of cruelty. But despite the definitive ban on continuing in this activity related to animals and above all, a definitive ban on keeping any animals, they have started again! Fortunately, we maintained our vigilance until last year. In collaboration with the services of the DDPP (Departmental Directorate of Population Protection) of the Oise, the police, and in the presence of our partner shelters, we have been able once again to rescue these poor beings who were dependent on them.

A new memorable seizure

On May 5th 2017 these repeat offenders were taken into custody. That day, we discovered animals living in mud, without care, without food or water, some locked up in small poorly maintained pens and without protection from the cold or the rain: about twenty goats and their kids, two billy goats, cats, dogs, and even the body of a chicken dried up in a transport crate, and an abandoned cat corpse behind a door…

A rebirth for the survivors

The goats that were saved are now all in great shape! Half of them have taken up residence at the Filémon refuge, where they share their time between the sheepfold, heated for the cold days and the green meadows, coloured with a thousand wildflowers during the sunny days. The others joined the refuge at Bonheur des Chevaux in Lot-et-Garonne. They enjoy a plot of several hectares, which One Voice had financed the fence so that they can be welcomed in the best possible conditions.

The cats, meanwhile, were taken care of by the AIMAA shelter of Épernay and the Oisemont Protection Animal shelter. Finally, they have found peace. Thanks to the patience and constant care from the shelter staff, these traumatized individuals can now trust humans!

Life is not less rosy for the dogs entrusted to the AIMAA shelter of Epernay … Gustave Flaubert has found a perfect place within the family. Georges Sand now walks without a leash despite her eyesight problems and the slightest walk is an immense source of joy for him. Isaac, for his part, quickly adapted to his new environment. It’s a dog’s love with a strong character, who now likes to express himself and who has become the little prince of the house …

A big thank you to all our donors who allowed the Cell Zoe to maintain a long-term surveillance of these torturers of animals and to eventually prosecute them, to organize the rescues and to put the victims into safe partner shelters. One Voice has provided funding for veterinary care during the years of litigation. This chain of solidarity is essential to reduce cruelty!

Maya: No news from the authorities, One Voice sounds the alarm in front of the circus on May 26th at 10 am near Narbonne

Maya: No news from the authorities, One Voice sounds the alarm in front of the circus on May 26th at 10 am near Narbonne

Maya: No news from the authorities, One Voice sounds the alarm in front of the circus on May 26th at 10 am near Narbonne
26.05.2018
Narbonne
Maya: No news from the authorities, One Voice sounds the alarm in front of the circus on May 26th at 10 am near Narbonne
Exploitation for shows

150000 signatures in 7 months,
5 legal actions, expert appraisals from recognized specialists from all over the world, an overwhelming veterinary report following an inspection ordered by the prefecture, 3 rallies, several hours of film footage, a petition signed by personalities. All this and Maya remains locked within a circus truck, the public authorities seem to be allowing themselves to be walked all over. And the ministry turnsa deaf ear to our requests for a meeting ..

The next knockback, we learn that a place in Britain is preparing to host an elephant from a French circus. This place is far too small and not up to standard required, it further lacks veterinary care. One Voice is therefore mobilizing once more for the elephant, and organizes an action in front of the circus that will be operating on Saturday May 26th at 10am in Montredon-des-Corbières near Narbonne.

It has been more than a month since we had any news from the Lot-et-Garonne prefecture, which refuses to meet with us.

A few weeks ago, we received images of Maya, locked up day and night in a truck, filmed by a whistle-blower who had access to the circus. Maya has not been seen since, either by visitors or in her winter quarters.

Sensitive information on the future of this elephant has been disseminated, information that we kept secret since April, so as not to risk
compromising the future of Maya. But today we learn from one of our international partners, that an old elephant coming from France would be expected in Great Britain, in a place we greatly doubt that is suitable for Maya herself or the elephant Lechmee and any other elephant from a circus. Maya, like all the animals of the captive industry, must finally be able to live her life in a vast, adapted space, and benefit from proper supervised veterinary care.

Today, we are writing to the Ministry of the Ecological and Solidarity Transition with the Born Free Foundation, our British partner, to urge it to urgently support the rescue of Maya through the Lot-et-Garonne Prefecture and transfer her to a suitable place.

Find all the news of Maya on our blog:

Share on

He kills a puppy with an axe in front of his children

He kills a puppy with an axe in front of his children

He kills a puppy with an axe in front of his children
24.05.2018
Grignon
He kills a puppy with an axe in front of his children
Domestic animals

Athena lived the worst kind of life! Accidentally wounded, the usual violence from the father of the family who would eventually give her an atrocious death. He killed her with an axe, burned her and buried in a wood after putting her down for having a broken leg. Our Cell Zoe has pressed charges, we are asking for exemplary charges.

Athena was barely three months old and lived in Grignon in a stepfamily with five children. Wednesday, April 11threturning home from work, the mother accidentally drove over the paw of this adorable little Beauceron dog. To avoid having to pay for the vet care, the stepfather asks the vet to put it down, his wife intervened, the children were terrified. The veterinarian does not perform the euthanasia, but does not offer to help and didn’t warn the authorities either, while the puppy was clearly in danger of death and the children were afraid. This is the first step towards the nightmare.

An outburst of rage without limit on a baby dog

When the veterinarian refuses, the man decides to kill the poor wounded animal himself. Horror of horrors, he chooses the axe as a weapon of the crime, and proceeds to kill him under the horrified gaze of one of the children who will call the gendarmes himself while the rest of the family is in a state of shock. He will burn Athena’s body in the woods to better hide his wrongdoing. He will also be seen by a witness through the trees digging a pit in which he would throw the remains of the murdered puppy. Thanks to them this extreme act of violence has been discovered and will not go unpunished.

The link between domestic violence and violence towards pets

This chilling affair is exemplary in the link it denotes between the violence suffered by the children and their mother and those perpetrated towards the puppy. For ten years this particularly violent man had been in the habit of beating brutally and threatening his partner and children with death, as a witness close to the couple said: « He is capable of killing them all.The dog was the first sign of what could have happened to them« . « It was just slaps of obedience! » the accused will say by way of explanation, without ever expressing the slightest regret, neither for Athena, nor for her abused family …

What can be said of a child who has been beaten for eleven years and has a handicapped foot, forced to watch his beloved animal get hit again and again by an axe without any chance of escaping? Scape-goat for his stepfather he will later tell the authorities. « He hit me with the palm of his hand in the  face … (…) At the same time he cries, he says words like that I should not have existed and that I am a good for nothing (…) it happens every week he hits me there are weeks where it’s every day (…) he says I’m rotten and that I do not deserve anything (…) he tells me he will kill me« . Between his personal condition and that of Athena, it is easy to understand what connection the little boy could have made. What will be the psychological consequences for him?

For the plaintiff, we demand an exemplary penalty

We filed a complaint immediately after the discovery of the facts. The torturer appeared April 18th2018 at the Criminal Court Albertville for « serious abuse on pets » but also for « intrafamilial violence ». The judgment was postponed until May 24th pending the psychiatric assessment of the defendant. Our Cell Zoe will be there for Athena but also to highlight the heroic role of the child, who must be completely protected.

In addition to claiming exemplary punishment against this man, sign our petition to demand with us the creation of a criminal record of violence and acts of cruelty perpetrated towards animals. This is to better detect and punish those responsible for the facts, not in function of the type of species the victim is. It is untenable, how many more deaths, children under terror, lives broken?