Le blog de One Voice

On the One Voice blog you can follow the news about good causes for animals. Discover our surveys and campaigns for the protection of animal rights.


Valentin’s last voyage

Thursday 11 February 2016 - 11

Valentin was born on the 13th of February 1996 in the confines of a pool, no place for an orca. He would die there on the 12th of October 2015, at the age of 19, having never left Marineland, Antibes.

The orcas circle nervously in the pool. Shouka and Kim, as well as Sharkane, the Godmother, who is supervising the birth and who will soon guide the child to the surface. First the tailfin, followed by the body, little by little from Freya's stomach. In a cloud of blood, Valentin enters the world. He discovers the tiny universe in which he will live for his for his whole life: the concrete walls, the turbulent, chlorine tasting water, the noise. And above the water, he sees buildings, stands and humans walking around.
Walls everywhere. The orca basin as it was in 1996 is now home to the dolphins. Five inmates are contained there. First of all, Freya has to teach her son not to injure himself on the concrete walls, and to learn how to break his momentum so as not to hit the walls whilst playing. Nothing prepares a cetacean, even one born in captivity, to live in a tank.

At six months, Valentin takes part in his first shows, swimming under his mother and nursing to the background noise of clapping. When weaned at the age of one, he quickly learns from the trainers that if he has to work if he wants fish. He must be disciplined and not play around during the show. He also has to accept the separation from his mother, isolated in another basin. Little Prince Valentin becomes very popular, with a fan club and a Facebook page. Teenagers exchange his best photos annotated with hearts. We easily recognise his beauty spot to the right of his throat.

Val is the second orca to be born in Marineland after Shouka, Sharkane's daughter, her oldest of three years and his playmate. He is also the first surviving child of Freya, who was thought to be infertile because of previous x-ray treatment. Before Val, she had given birth to her first stillborn in March 1991, then a second in 1993. After Val's birth, she would go on to lose three more children, in 2001 and 2003. So you can imagine how much she loves and protects her son. After her last miscarriage, an already unwell Freya drops into a depression. Floating away from the others, she doesn't participate in the shows anymore, and no longer obeys the trainers. She comes up occasionally and hits her head against the windows of the main pool, again and again, consumed by sadness.
Valentin takes this all in, and suffers to see his mother in pain.
She had already been hit hard by the departure of her adored half-sister Shouka in 2002. The young orca had been sent to Vallejo in the United States, where she would live on her own for ten years.
As for Valentin, he begins to exhibit stereotypical displacement behaviour which he will repeat for the rest of his life: his stomach in the air, hitting his forehead against the sides of his pool next to the "trainers cave".

Upon Freya's death in June 2015, Valentin's world would collapse once again. His mother was the last orca caught by Marineland. Constantly ill during her short life, she had visible scars from x-rays on her side. A "heart-attack," declared Marineland, but Freya had other reasons to die.
Leaving behind a bewildered little family in her wake, unguided having lost their matriarch, it is a terrible shock for the five surviving members. But Marineland has no time to let them grieve for Freya, putting on a show the very same evening, to "distract" them from their sorrow and to not lose clients. Valentin however, is not "distracted" by the show, nor by any future show. A feeling of emptiness and abandonment takes hold that only the son loved by a orca can understand.
A brutal change in power relations takes place within the walls of the basin: Freya now dead, Val is no longer the protected little prince. His social status collapses and he finds himself in front of his nagging half-sister in charge of two children, and his shy half-brother, Inouk. Tensions build and fights erupt. Freya is no longer there to keep order. By summer 2015, Valentin is a shadow, floating motionless on his own in a corner of the chemical blue pool. Around Val, a fairground atmosphere: incessant music, the noise of visitors, food odours and lighting until late at night. Valentin doesn't listen any longer, he hardly moves anymore.

The days go by. The temperature increases. Then suddenly, the sky opens. Heavy rain falls on the region. Marineland is submerged by mud and dirt and the basin waters become yellowy brown. The survivors are closed off into a small lateral basin to protect them from the infected water. They fight and they bite each other. Wikie falls ill and is isolated. Is Valentin still alive? Did he not survive seeing the collapse of his family? Has he swallowed something toxic? Has he been injured by a stand chair catapulted by the wind? Have his injuries become infected? Did he die during the flooding? We know nothing.
On Monday the 12 th of October, Marineland management publish a brief press release: "Marineland is extremely sad to announce the death today at 12.00 of Valentin, an orca born in the park", adding two days later: "The first physical examination of Valentin, who died a few days ago, shows an intestinal torsion like that which can occur in a horse or a dog".
But orcas are not dogs, and twisted intestines caused by stress don't happen to them at sea. Every day, they travel an average of 160km and dive to depths of more than 100 metres. Valentin only completed one short journey in his short life, from Marineland Antibes to the knackery.
An enormous crane lifted his body from the crib that had become his grave, as it had done for many others before him. Since the opening in 1970 of Marineland, Antibes, nine other adults have died young, on top of all the miscarriages. Calypso died at 11 years of age, Clovis at 4, Kim at 14, Betty at 13, Kim2 at 27, Sharkane at 23, Tanouk at 14, and Freya at 32. The average age of a wild orca is between 50 and 80 years old. Granny, the matriarch of J Pod has reached 104 years of age.
Valentin, he only made it to 19...

If his parents had not been captured, today Valentin would be a wonderful male cutting through the waves in the Iceland sea with his big straight fin. He would swim alongside his mother, still alive with her life ahead of her, and with all of his brothers, sisters, uncles and aunts. He would hunt herring, play, have many close friends in other tribes, and have some children here and there. Every day, his life would be a new adventure in the icy fjord water. But man had decided otherwise. Valentin spent his life in a dungeon, his stomach ravaged by ulcers, his chin cut from rubbing against the concrete tanks, and his backfin drooping over time.
This is not how orcas live

Yvon Godefroid


Comment from LAPINOU06

Ces animaux n'ont rien à faire là ils souffrent ils sont exploités et forcés à faire des choses juste pour l'amusement et pour l'argent! Mais a-t-on pensé à eux? Ne serait ce qu'une seule fois? Il faut cesser ce genre de choses pour eux ce n'est simplement qu'une prison.

Comment from carole

Que nous sommes vils nous les hommes, nous faisons de l'argent de tout et surtout de la misère animale, de quel droit capturons-nous des animaux sauvages pour les enfermer et les laisser mourir !

Comment from Viv@

Quand on ne sait rien, on se tait !

Comment from Marie

Condamné à perpétuité sans avoir commis le moindre crime. Comme tous les animaux captifs. Merci One voice d'avoir mis en ligne ce texte remarquqble, en espérant de tout coeur que cela puisse contribuer à faire cesser ces abominations que constituent l'emprisonnement et l'exploitation des orques, des dauphins, de tous les animaux. TOUS.

Comment from Homps dominique

C'est très triste, les pauvres : vivre en prison toute leur vie.

Comment from Babeth

Merci de laisser les animaux vivre en liberté, comme nous ! Nous n'avons pas le droit de les mettre en cage ni dans les parcs, par contre, nous avons le devoir de les protéger !
Nous sommes en train d'exterminer les animaux peu à peu; nous les hommes, les plus grands prédateurs de tous mes temps !
Il est grand temps de s'en apercevoir et vite ...

Comment from Pascale

À 2 jours de la Saint Valentin.... Un signe?
Je suis sûre qu'un jour , j'espère... Il faut tout faire pour que l'être humain retrouve sa connection perdue avec la terre !
L'animal souffre physiquement et moralement... Ça nous le savons tous... certains préfèrent l'oublier pour ne pas avoir mauvaise conscience... certains abusent de ce fait pour gagner de l'argent... Marineland... Cirque....Élevage sous contrainte.... Éducation sous contrainte....
Persévérons !!!! L'histoire de Valentin est un exemple très clair du ressenti animal que l'homme , aveugle ou sourd ou vaniteux ou pervers ( dans le strict du terme) ou manipulateur ou égocentrique , refuse d'admettre ou d'accepter parce que ça le dérange et perturbe son quotidien....
Valentin tu es mieux là où tu es je t'assure... Tu as souffert de ton vivant.... Je prie très fort pour que ta mort soit ta libération...

Comment from dominique loup solitaire

Quelle race sommes-nous pour autoriser de telles atrocités. Leur univers c'est l'océan, leur patrie c'est leur famille et leur vie c'est la liberté. Nous leur offrons un pénitencier dans les pires conditions physiques et psychologiques. Une petite victime de plus pour le plaisir de quelques-uns. Ces enclos sont des mouroirs et je reste consternée de voir ce que l'homme reste capable de faire sans âme ni conscience.

Comment from Kay

Votre article est entièrement juste et malheureusement vrai...

Cependant, je me permets d'y apporter deux petites modifications :
- Certes, le poisson est la motivation mais même si les orques ne travaillent pas, au Marineland, elles sont nourries normalement. Il y a des jours où par exemple telle orque ne participe pas au spectacle car elle n'est pas d'humeur et en rien ça ne change sa ration de poisson ni les soins et l'amour que les soigneurs leur porte.
- De plus, certes, il y a eu un show le jour de la mort de Freya mais le soir ils ont passé une vidéo hommage à elle et lui ont fait un discours. Ça ne change rien c'est sûr mais c'est un beau geste tout de même et il ne faut pas l'oublier.

Comment from uria

quoi dire, que j'y mettrais bien certains humains... pauvre petit et tous ces malheureux animaux qu'on maltraite, tue, dépèce et l'humain peut être bon mais il y a le fric et lui, il mène le monde.

Comment from Siska

C'est honteux de les laisser dans des espaces si petits et sous prétexte de leur intelligence leur faire faire des pitreries pour amuser les humains c'est d'une bassesse. Ces animaux comme beaucoup d'autres doivent vivre dans leur contexte naturel.

Add a comment

I accept that publication of my comments is subject to the code of conduct.

Code of conduct.

In our policy of non-violence, no comment inciting hate, or which is offensive, discriminates or is slanderous will be published; this also applies to any comment intended to create publicity, or written in SMS language.

Thank you for your understanding.

The One Voice Team


One Voice is an independent organisation. It is only funded by private donations.


Social networks

Facebook - Twitter - Vimeo

+33 (0)3 88 35 67 30 - info@one-voice.fr
Contact presse : +33 (0)6 43 26 78 80 - presse@one-voice.fr
One Voice - 1 A place des Orphelins - 67000 Strasbourg - FRANCE -