Wednesday 25 October 2023 | 10

One Voice is bringing a civil case to the tribunal against a bird poacher in Montauban

One Voice is bringing a civil case to the tribunal against a bird poacher in Montauban

Mis à jour le 27 February 2024

On 26 October at 9am, we will be at the Montauban legal tribunal for the blue tits, great tits, goldfinches, and blackcaps who are victims of a poacher that lives in the south of Tarn-et-Garonne. The man, not content with capturing and killing protected birds, resorted to illegal traditional hunting methods. We will be there once again against these cruel practices and for all the animals who continue to be a target of them.

Hr blog

Updated 27 October:

Shock and frustration are appropriate when faced with the summary penalty order given on 26 October 2023, which sentenced the defendant to a simple fine of 1000 euros plus compensation.

The ruling indicated that “in view of the seriousness of the facts, it does not seem necessary to give a prison term”. This shows serious denial of the captured birds’ distress and agony. We will not stop defending them against poachers.

It was a macabre spectacle that the agents from the French Office of Biodiversity (OFB) discovered during their search of this poacher's home in Tarn-et-Garonne. There they found that seven goldfinches were being kept prisoner to attract other birds with their song, while twenty-three individuals from other protected species were found lifeless in traps. Their capture is performed in the trapper’s garden, where the victims, who cannot resist the calls of one of their own, have had the misfortune to land, only to find themselves trapped in nets or stuck to perches covered in glue. The distress and agony that these tits and blackcaps have to endure before they take their last breath is unimaginable.

Faced with a resurgence in traditional hunting, we are keeping the pressure on

As well as having been killed while belonging to a protected species, these birds have been killed using methods that are themselves prohibited. Have we forgotten that glue hunting was ruled illegal by the State Council in 2021, following a decision made by none other than the European Court of Justice? And that the French institution once again proved us right a few months later by suspending and cancelling ministerial decrees relating to traditional hunting several times following this, after the government’s stubbornness in relation to persecuting birds?

Obviously caring as little about justice as they do about animals, those killing these little birds stubbornly go out of their way to continue to use these methods again. To the point where the government has given them the gift of ‘experimentation’, intended to show that the use of cages, nets, and decoys would be well and truly selective, which would justify these killings happening again in their eyes.

Zero tolerance for poachers

We will not let either the attempts to revive traditional hunting or the slightest complacency regarding poachers lie. In September 2022, we already succeeded in getting a man who had killed and sold thousands of robins sentenced with a six-month suspended prison sentence and a €25,000 fine. In February 2023, a repeat offender had to defend their actions in front of the courts.

As a civil party in the trial, we will once again give a voice to all of the birds that were killed and will ask for the highest possible penalty for this massacre at the Montauban legal tribunal on Thursday 26 October.

Translated from the French by Joely Justice

Marion Henriet
Hr blog

In the subject

Several thousand tenrecs killed in Réunion: yet hunting was illegal! Once again, a tribunal has noted that hunting Galliformes is illegal

Comments 10

I accept that publication of my comments is subject to the code of conduct.

trochu | Sunday 29 October 2023

Quelle justice lamentable et pitoyable que nous avons en France. Ces juges sont-ils seulement dignes d'occuper un tel poste au vu de leur indifférence, de leur manque de considération flagrant envers tous les animaux, mais aussi de leur manque cruel de sensibilité et d'amour envers les animaux. Ont-ils seulement conscience de ce que vivent ces oiseaux piégés dans l'horreur absolue par cet individu les laissant à l'agonie sans aucun scrupule alors que tous ces merveilleux oiseaux sont protégés et disparaissent de nos paysages toujours plus. En ne condamnant pas plus ce braconnier parmi tant d'autre ces autorités cautionnent le braconnage et la chasse et leur donnent raison, c'est juste honteux et scandaleux.

あい | Saturday 28 October 2023

恥ずかしいと思いませんか。
抵抗の出来ない、何の罪もない命を残酷な方法で捕らえ、苦しみの中で絶命させるなんて。
あなたに心から愛する存在がいたら、愛されたことがあるなら出来ない筈です。

marie-claude | Friday 27 October 2023

Quand il n'y aura plus d'oiseaux il n'y aura plus d'humains. La nature est importante.

Jane | Thursday 26 October 2023

lA JUSTICE N'EST PAS ASSEZ DISSUASIVE. Une peine ne devrait pas être avec sursis, c'est scandaleux de torturer des petits oiseaux qui ne demandent qu'à vivre. La chasse est d'un autre âge et il faut évoluer